TREN
🧪 ESANS.COM.TR ACADEMY — Technical Formulation Portal
🧪
Esans.com.tr Academy
Technical Formulation Portal
← All Articles
Molecules & Accords ↗

Lyral (HICC): What It Is, Why It Was Banned, Current Regulations & Alternatives

Lyral (HICC) was once perfumery's most beloved muguet molecule — now it is prohibited under EU cosmetics law and IFRA standards. Here is everything formulators need to know about the ban, the science behind it, and the modern alternatives.

Esans.com.tr Academy ·✍️ Esans Academy Technical Team ·~10 min read·Updated: 21.10.2026
FIGURE 01Molecule Identity
TOPMIDDLE ★BASE
🌸 FLORAL FAMILY
Volatility: Middle note (30 min – 3 h)
01

Lyral (HICC): The Rise and Fall of a Muguet Legend

Lyral was, for decades, one of perfumery's most beloved floral molecules. It is now the prime suspect on banned raw material lists. This page is not a usage guide — it is a warning page. If you have Lyral stock or old formulae containing it, you will find out exactly what to do here.

Role: Floral (muguet / lily of the valley) — no longer permittedTypical usage rate: — (EU/IFRA ban) Form: Liquid (colourless–pale yellow)Solubility: alcohol / DPG / IPM CAS: 31906-04-4 (and 51414-25-6) Natural/Synthetic: SyntheticFamily: Floral / muguet aldehydeVolatility: medium (heart note)Tenacity: moderate — a few hoursDiffusion: medium–high

Its chemical name is Hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde (HICC). Trade names include Lyral (IFF) and Kovanol. It entered the market in the 1960s and, with its fresh, aqueous lily-of-the-valley (muguet) character, spread into everything from soap to fine fragrance. It was inexpensive, potent, and long-lasting. That very ubiquity proved to be its undoing.

The regulatory information on this page is for general guidance only. The situation at time of publication may change. Before making any production or import decisions, verify the current IFRA Standards and TİTCK sources directly.
02

How Does It Smell? What Does It Evoke?

Lyral's magic lay in its character. No absolute can be obtained from the natural lily-of-the-valley flower — the bloom has a scent but will not yield it to distillation. Lyral was the closest synthetic bridge to that otherwise unobtainable fragrance.

Scent Profile

  • ✓ Fresh lily of the valley / muguet blossom
  • ✓ Aqueous, dew-drop sensation
  • ✓ Lightly green and soft
  • ✓ Crisp and transparent
  • ✓ Long-lingering trail
  • ✓ Soapy, clean touch

💭 What Does It Evoke?

Cleanliness · Freshness · Innocence · Spring · Transparency · Brightness

A composition containing Lyral sat somewhere between "freshly laundered linen" and "a spring garden." That is precisely why it appeared in both luxury fragrances and fabric softeners. The problem was exactly that ubiquity: skin came into contact with this molecule far too frequently and in far too many contexts.

03

Why Was It Banned? The Sensitisation Problem and the Process

In brief: Lyral is a potent skin sensitiser. Sensitisation differs from an allergy reaction — the molecule "trains" the immune system in the skin; with repeated exposure, the body can develop a permanent response to the substance. Once sensitised, a person may experience contact dermatitis at even very low concentrations.

A critical distinction: Lyral is synthetic, but the reason for its ban is not that it is synthetic. Safety is determined not by origin (natural or synthetic) but by the molecule itself and the level of use. In fact, most of the most strictly restricted allergens regulated by IFRA are found in natural fragrance oils. Lyral was eliminated solely because clinical data showed a high sensitisation rate.

In SCCS (EU Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety) assessments and dermatological patch tests, Lyral consistently ranked among the most frequently positive-reacting fragrance ingredients. The process unfolded in stages:

  1. 1999 — First warning

    SCCNFP classified Lyral among high-risk allergens and made labelling mandatory.

  2. 2003–2013 — Labelling period

    Declaration on the ingredient list became compulsory above certain thresholds; IFRA restrictions tightened progressively.

  3. 2017 — EU decision

    An amendment to the EU Cosmetics Regulation (1223/2009) added HICC to Annex II (prohibited substances).

  4. 2019 — Market withdrawal

    The transition period expired; the sale of cosmetics containing Lyral in the EU market effectively ceased. IFRA also placed the molecule on its prohibited list.

  5. TİTCK approach

    Turkish cosmetics legislation closely follows the EU regulation; Lyral should therefore be treated as unusable in Turkey as well. Verify the current position with TİTCK directly.

TopicLyral (HICC) StatusSource / Context
EU Cosmetics RegulationProhibited (Annex II)Amendment to 1223/2009, 2017
IFRA StandardProhibitedCurrent IFRA edition
Turkey (TİTCK)Follows EU — not permittedMust be verified
Core issueSkin sensitisationClinical patch tests
ReasonNot that it is synthetic — the molecule's own risk profileSCCS assessment
04

What Should a Manufacturer with Lyral-Containing Formulae or Stock Do?

What is needed here is not panic but a systematic approach. Perhaps you found a Lyral-containing accord in an old notebook, or there is a bottle that has been sitting on the shelf for years. Here is your roadmap.

  1. Take stock of your inventory

    List every formula and stock item containing HICC. It may be hidden inside older commercial fragrance oils — request an IFRA compliance declaration and full ingredient breakdown from your supplier.

  2. Halt sales and production

    Do not place any finished product containing Lyral on the EU or Turkish market. Non-compliant cosmetics cannot be legally marketed.

  3. Reformulate (reformulation)

    Rebuild the muguet character using modern, permitted alternatives. The goal is not an identical replica but a redesigned balance.

  4. Dispose of remaining stock appropriately

    Destroy remaining HICC according to hazardous chemical waste procedures; do not pour it down the drain. Store any mixtures containing flammable solvents safely.

  5. Clarify the responsible-person obligations

    Product notification and safety assessment responsibilities and notification procedures are separate matters. Update the safety assessment for any reformulated product; consult TİTCK for the definitive procedure.

Tip: Replacing a single molecule one-for-one is rarely sufficient in reformulation. As a "muguet aldehyde," Lyral simultaneously contributed greenness, wateriness, and volume to a composition. No single alternative typically covers all three functions — you will usually need to build a accord from two or three molecules.
05

Current Muguet Alternatives & Frequently Asked Questions

The good news is that perfumery can still smell of muguet without Lyral. A new generation of permitted molecules has filled the gap in both safety profile and scent quality. Below are the alternatives a formulator can bring to the bench.

AlternativeSupplier / Trade NameCharacterWhere it shines
NymphealIFFClean muguet, aqueous-green, high qualityThe closest modern bridge to Lyral
MahonialFirmenichMuguet + light metallic-green brightnessFresh floral hearts
Florosa / FlorolFirmenichSoft, soapy muguet-freesiaSoap and clean accords
Cyclamen AldehydeVariousGreen, aqueous, lightly melonFreshens muguet accords
Lilial (caution)—Muguet-likeAlso restricted in the EU — do not use; verify current status
Warning: Lilial (BMHCA), which gained popularity as an alternative after Lyral's ban, has itself been prohibited in EU cosmetics. When selecting alternatives, look to the current permitted list rather than old favourites. Verify the IFRA status and category limits of every molecule you choose at the time of use.

When building a muguet accord, also consider the base side for anchoring the floral note: a soft musk (for example a molecule such as Tonalide, verifying its current status) or a light woody-amber base will balance the volatility of the top florals. For richness, a natural balsamic touch — labdanum, for instance — adds depth to a green-aqueous heart.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Lyral still be purchased, and is it legal to use?
Its use in cosmetics is prohibited under EU law and IFRA standards; Turkish TİTCK regulation follows the EU. It may be available from some sources for research or collection purposes, but do not use it in any product you intend to place on the market. Verify the current regulations before purchasing.
Are HICC and Lyral the same thing?
Yes. HICC is the chemical abbreviation for the molecule; Lyral is IFF's trade name for it. Other trade names exist, such as Kovanol, but all refer to the same prohibited molecule.
Why was Lyral banned — does it cause cancer?
The ban is not related to cancer. The reason is its potent skin sensitisation potential. Clinical patch tests showed a high risk of triggering a permanent allergic reaction (contact dermatitis) with repeated exposure.
Was Lyral banned because it is synthetic?
No. The ban relates to the molecule's risk profile, not to its synthetic origin. Many of the most strictly restricted allergens are found in natural essential oils. Safety depends on the molecule and the level of use, not on the source.
Which is the best alternative to Lyral?
In terms of scent quality and closeness, Nympheal is the most widely favoured modern bridge. Florosa stands out for a soapy, clean character; Mahonial for green brightness. In most cases the best result comes from combining two or three of these in an accord.
Can I sell an old fragrance I have that contains Lyral?
You cannot use it in new products intended for the market. Audit your inventory, halt sales, and reformulate with permitted alternatives. Consult TİTCK for the definitive procedure.
Does Nympheal or Lyral smell better?
Most perfumers find Nympheal cleaner and more "true muguet." Lyral was a fine molecule in its time, but Nympheal surpasses it in both scent clarity and safety profile. Test them side by side in your own formula.
Is it possible to obtain muguet as a natural extract?
No commercial absolute or oil can be obtained from lily-of-the-valley flowers — the bloom produces a scent but will not yield it through extraction. For this reason, a muguet note is always constructed as a molecular accord. There is no natural alternative, which is why synthetic building blocks are used.
Has Lilial also been banned — can I use it?
Lilial (BMHCA) has also been restricted under EU cosmetics legislation. Although it was for a time considered an alternative to Lyral, it is no longer a safe choice. Turn to current molecules such as Nympheal and Florosa, and verify their status before use.
Was Lyral a long-lasting molecule?
It had moderate tenacity — detectable for a few hours. However, longevity is determined by the formula as a whole, not by a single molecule. To extend the muguet character, support it with musk and woody base notes.
How should I dispose of Lyral stock?
Dispose of it according to hazardous chemical waste procedures; do not pour it down the drain or into general waste. Store any mixtures containing flammable solvents away from static sources in a well-ventilated area, and comply with local waste management regulations.
Can I replace Lyral with a single alternative molecule in reformulation?
This is rarely sufficient. Lyral simultaneously contributed greenness, wateriness, and volume to a composition. No single alternative fully covers all three roles; you will generally need to build an accord from two or three molecules and redesign the balance from scratch.

Continue

🛒 Related Product
All Products
Browse products →
🧪 Related Tool
Perfume Calculator
Open calculator →

esans.com.tr

Explore →